repertify.ai
Materia Medica

Lobelia Inflata

Indian Tobacco
42 sectionsBoericke · 13Clarke · 29

At a glance

Cardinal features · auto-extracted from Boericke · Clarke
  • nausea, vomiting and dyspepsia
  • Suppressed discharges
  • Catarrhal jaundice
  • Chionanth

Essence

Prologue
Boericke

Indian Tobacco

Is a vaso-motor stimulant; increases the activity of all vegetative processes; spends its force mainly upon the pneumogastric nerve, producing a depressed relaxed condition with oppression of the chest and epigastrium, impeded respiration, nausea and vomiting.

  • Languor, relaxation of muscles, nausea, vomiting and dyspepsia are the general indications that point to the use of this remedy, in asthma and gastric affections.
  • Best adapted to light complexioned fleshy people.
  • Bad effects of drunkenness.
  • Suppressed discharges (Sulph).
  • Diphtheria.
  • Catarrhal jaundice (Chionanth).
Want to know if Lobelia fits your case? Repertify reads the case as the patient speaks, scores every rubric against the Kentian hierarchy, and cross-validates Lobelia against Boericke, Kent and Clarke in parallel. Open the workspace · 30 days free, no card.

Mentals

Symptoms — Mind
Clarke

Mental inquietude; great depression and exhaustion; presentiment of death, and

dyspnoea.—Sobbing-like a child —Violent raving with flushing of face and palpitation, every

evening, after an hour's sleep.—Lost his reason and became convulsed; it required several men to

hold him; this continued till death.—Felt he was dying, with distress at chest.—Felt he was dying,

but was unconcerned.

Generals

Symptoms — Generalities
Clarke

Lancinating pains throughout body, extending to ends of fingers and toes;

trembling of limbs, likewise of whole body feeling of depression; unusual lassitude; prolonged

weakness; exhaustion state of stupefaction; convulsions, sometimes such as to require two men

to hold the patient, followed by death; violent convulsive jerkings, followed by death.—Other

symptoms coming on when a discharge ceases.

Modalities

Modalities
Boericke
Worse
tobacco, afternoon, slightest motion, cold, especially cold washing
Better
by rapid walking; (chest pain), toward evening, and from warmth

Head

Head
Boericke

Vertigo, and fear of death. Gastric headache, with nausea, vomiting, and great prostration; worse, afternoon until midnight; tobacco. Dull, heavy pain.

Symptoms — Head
Clarke

Cerebral suffering; giddiness; vertigo.——Vertigo with nausea.—Headache with slight

  • giddiness.
  • —Vertigo as if starting from |.
  • eye.
  • —Feeling of disorder: at first in occiput; afterwards

in forehead; in head, after a meal, increasing to a violent aching pain, with heat in

face.—Headache < by coughing; brain racked by cough which causes intolerable

  • pain.
  • —Heaviness in head, with lassitude in back.
  • —Cephalalgia, esp.
  • during movement, and when

ascending a staircase, chiefly in vertex; with vertigo and lancinations in temples; dull pain and

heat in occiput, in evening; violent, in forehead, from time to time (during the fever).—Outward

pressing in both temples.—Tension in head, in evening, esp. in occiput, or else with heat in

face.—Aching in occiput, sometimes chiefly in open air, or else diminished on covering the

head.—Pressive pain on |. side of occiput; < at night and from

  • motion.
  • —Wens.
  • —Seborrhcea.
  • —Seborrhcea of scalp smelling offensively (produced in an infant
  • every time one drop of Lob.
  • i.
  • ac.
  • @ was taken.
  • —Cooper.
  • ).

Eyes

Symptoms — Eyes
Clarke
  • Burning in eyes; (hemiopia).
  • —Pain and soreness in r.
  • eye.
  • -—Burning in eyes.
  • —Itching in

angles of (1.) lids —Pressing pain in eyeballs, most in upper part—Pupils dilated —Vision dim.

Ears

Ears
Boericke

Deafness due to suppressed discharges or eczema. Shooting pain from throat.

Symptoms — Ears
Clarke
  • Aching in |.
  • ear.
  • —Shooting pain extending into 1.
  • ear from painful spot in throat to 1.
  • of
  • larynx.
  • —Sudden shutting up ofr.
  • ear, as if stopped by a plug, at 2 p.
  • m.
  • , > boring finger in

ear.—(Profuse-discharge from the ear.—Constantly recurring earache and deafness following

suppressed otorrhcea.)

Face

Face
Boericke

Bathed in cold sweat. Sudden pallor.

Symptoms — Face
Clarke

Heat of face; sweat on face, with nausea.—Chilly feeling in 1. cheek extending to ear.

Mouth

Mouth
Boericke

Profuse flow of saliva; acrid burning taste; mercurial taste; tenacious mucus, tongue coated white.

Symptoms — Mouth
Clarke

Flow of clammy saliva in mouth (with nausea).—Sharp, disagreeable taste in mouth,

esp. at tip of tongue and back of throat—Accumulation of saliva; frequent expectoration of a

very watery saliva; copious salivation.—Tongue white, charged with a thick coating, on r. side

only.—Acrid, burning taste in mouth; bitter, with foul tongue and thirst.

Throat

Symptoms — Throat
Clarke

Scraping in throat; changing into aching and nausea, which in turn is succeeded by

retching, with squeezing and convulsive heaving in larynx; with risings and burning, arising

from stomach; with sensation of rawness in throat, and constriction in cesophagus; with great

dryness, which is not removed by drinking, after a meal.—Burning in throat, which becomes a

scraping sensation; increased secretion of viscid saliva, with scraping, nausea, and risings;

burning scraping from velum palati to larynx; < on swallowing, and with frequent hawking, by

reason of an increased secretion of mucus in throat, burning followed by dryness, during the

forenoon.—Viscid mucus in throat—Tough mucus on fauces, causing frequent hawking.—Aching

in cesophagus: with nausea, griping in abdomen, and emission of fetid wind; along cesophagus,

as far as stomach, worse in certain parts, and esp. below the larynx.—Sensation in cesophagus as

if it contracted itself from below upwards.—Deglutition impeded as by a foreign body; in

swallowing, sensation as if something rose in larynx, and prevented the food from descending.

Stomach

Stomach
Boericke
  • Acidity, flatulence, shortness of breath after eating.
  • Heartburn with profuse flow of saliva.
  • Extreme nausea and vomiting.
  • Morning sickness.
  • Faintness and weakness at epigastrium. Profuse salivation, with good appetite.
  • Profuse sweat and prostration.
  • Cannot bear smell or taste of tobacco.
  • Acrid, burning taste; acidity, with contractive feeling in pit of stomach.
  • Flatulence, shortness of breath after eating.
  • Heartburn.
Symptoms — Stomach
Clarke

Anorexia.—Frequent risings, with accumulation of water in mouth; frequent

regurgitation of an acid and burning liquid; acidity in stomach, with sensation of constriction in

pit of stomach.—Frequent and violent hiccough, with abundant accumulation of water.—Pyrosis,

sometimes constant, or else with accumulation of saliva—Heartburn and running of water from

mouth.—Faintness, weakness, and an indescribable feeling at epigastrium, from excessive use of

tea or tobacco.—Violent and constant loathing, with shuddering and shivering; relaxation of the

stomach, sometimes with loathing, or with a very marked sensation of anti-peristaltic movements

(but without nausea).—Nausea and vomiting during pregnancy, with profuse running of water

  • from mouth.
  • —Burning in stomach.
  • —Feeling of weight in stomach.
  • —Nausea: in morning,

disappearing after taking a draught of water; with cold sweat on face; great disposition to vomit,

without vomiting.—Vomiting: of all kinds, even the most violent; with sighing, and continual

nausea; vomiting of food after a meal, esp. hot food—Vomiting, with cold perspiration of

face.—Dyspepsia.—Pain in stomach; sensation of weakness in stomach; or else in pit of stomach,

with oppression, which thence extends itself throughout chest.

Abdomen

Symptoms — Abdomen
Clarke

Aching in stomach: sometimes after eating but very little; after the meal, with

fulness and gurgling in abdomen; ascending towards chest, which becomes oppressed; with

nausea; accumulation of water in mouth, and retching.—Pressure in pit of stomach; across body

into spinal marrow, as by a plug, by intermitting action, becoming each time stronger; as from a

weight, when fasting, and after a meal, < chiefly in evening, also with vomiting of bile, and

oppression and anguish in chest, and pains in loins.—Violent and painful constriction in

epigastrium.—Cramps in stomach of various kinds.—Pains in abdomen; < after eating, with

cephalalgia, on returning from a walk, after a meal; cutting and drawing pains in abdomen;

griping and twisting, with nausea, violent risings, and emission of fetid wind.—Inflation of

abdomen, with dyspneea; flatulency and abundant emission of wind, with borborygmi in

abdomen, which are sometimes painful.

Stool

Symptoms — Stool and Anus
Clarke

Soft, whitish stool—Discharge of black blood after stool —Copious

haemorrhages from hemorrhoidal vessels.—Stools, like pap, soft, green; diarrhoea, sometimes

with frequent evacuations and confusion of head.

Urinary

Symptoms — Urinary Organs
Clarke

Increased secretion of urine, sometimes with want to urinate.—Frequent

emission of urine, even during night, and following morning (secretion of urine

diminished).—Urine cloudy: with loose deposit; deep red, with sediment of a dull red, soon

becoming turbid, with sediment of a rose colour, having small blue crystals.

Urinary
Boericke

Deep red color and copious red sediment.

Female

Symptoms — Female Sexual Organs
Clarke

During menstruation violent pain in sacrum.—Violent pain in the

sacrum, with fever, &c., supervening on suppression of the menses during their flow.

Respiratory

Respiratory
Boericke
  • Dyspnoea from constriction of chest; worse, any exertion.
  • Sensation of pressure or weight in chest; better by rapid walking.
  • Feels as if heart would stop.
  • Asthma; attacks, with weakness, felt in pit of stomach and preceded by prickling all over.
  • Cramp, ringing cough, short breath, catching at throat.
  • Senile emphysema.
Symptoms — Respiratory Organs
Clarke

Tickling in larynx, with frequent fits of short coughing; dryness in

throat, with sensation as though a solid body were there impeding both respiration and

deglutition.—Irritation which provokes coughing and expectoration.

Chest

Symptoms — Chest
Clarke

Respiration anxious, difficult, sobbing, with sensation of obstruction in chest; short,

imperfect, with sensation of fulness in chest; during inspiration, tickling in inferior region of

sternum; on breathing deeply, mitigation of the pressive pain at pit of stomach, and a feeling of

improved health.—Pain in chest, with breathing, while sitting after dinner, > moving

about.—Congestive pressure and weight in chest as if blood from extremities was filling it, > by

rapid walking —Want of breath, sometimes with respiration impeded, hurried, with frequent want

to breathe deeply; great difficulty in retaining the breath—Oppression of chest, causing laboured

respiration; asthma, chiefly with gastric symptoms, and sensation of weakness in pit of stomach;

dyspnoea, sometimes with a sort of presentiment of death; difficulty of respiration, after the least

fatigue, after washing in cold water, likewise from a current of air, and from heavy

food.—Asthmatic symptoms, hysterical asthma.—Violent pains in chest; < on breathing deeply;

on returning from a walk, after a meal.—Dyspncea and asthma, with sensation of a lump in the

throat, immediately above sternum.—Burning feeling in the chest, passing upwards.—Tension in

chest on turning body; burning pain as of excoriation at one spot below r. breast, with sensation

on breathing deeply, on sneezing, and on moving body quickly, as though something there were

dislodged, which in the midst of the suffering returns to its place; with a like sensation at pit of

stomach and 1. side; perforating pain at one spot in chest, extending sometimes to back and

shoulder-blade, < by movement, and with sensation of paralysis in the part affected.—Pain in the

breast.—Burning feeling in breast passing upward.—A tightness of the breast with heat in

forehead.—Drawing in |. breast from nipple to axilla.

Symptoms — Heart
Clarke

Precordial anxiety.—Deep-seated pain in region of heart.—Sensation of weakness

and pressure in epigastrium rising to heart——Sensation as if heart would stand still, a pain deep in

above heart.—Sensation of weakness in precordium extending upwards and

downwards.—Dyspneea and suffocation from every rapid movement, with vertigo, and threatened

loss of consciousness and a peculiar confusion of head.—Pulse small; and weak.

Neck & Back

Back
Boericke

Pain in sacrum; cannot bear slightest touch. Sits leaning forward.

Symptoms — Neck and Back
Clarke

Swelling and pain |. side of neck.—Rheumatic pain between the

  • scapule.
  • —Pain under r.
  • scapula < bending forward.
  • —In back: lassitude, with heaviness of head;

burning and incisive pains at lower part of spine; pains in loins; violent cramp-like squeezing in

posterior part of iliac region, which renders contact with anything, or motion, almost

insupportable.

Upper Limbs

Symptoms — Upper Limbs
Clarke

Rheumatic feeling in r. shoulder-joint; goes to 1. upper arm and around

elbow-joint.—Fine crawling stitches inside of r. deltoid —Pain in shoulders of an elderly lady

who had not menstruated for two years; Lob. i. relieved the pain and brought on

menstruation.—Rheumatic pain in r. elbow-joint—Sweat of palms, backs of hands dry and cool;

tips of fingers cold.

Lower Limbs

Symptoms — Lower Limbs
Clarke

In the legs, lassitude; acute tearing in tibia, extending to knee-joint; cramps

in calf in morning, on waking from a troubled sleep.—Inflammatory rheumatism in r. knee; with

tearing pains in fibula.

Skin

Skin
Boericke

Prickling, itching with intense nausea.

Symptoms — Skin
Clarke

Prickling itching of skin all over body.—Eruption between fingers, on dorsa of hands

and on forearms, vesicular itch-like pustules with tingling itching (Teste).—Vesicular eruption on

skin.

Sleep

Symptoms — Sleep
Clarke

Gaping; < followed by crawling in nose and sneezing; then gaping and belching of

wind.—Wakened early by very impressive dreams: arm amputated; wounded by a shot,

&c.—Disturbed sleep with many dreams, sometimes anxious; painful dreams; numerous, without

intermediate awakening; cold sweat.

Fever

Symptoms — Fever
Clarke

Pulse: accelerated; frequent and softer than usual; slow, in evening (after a stronger

dose).—Intermittent fever: commencing at noon, with great paleness and anorexia; quotidian,

sometimes every morning at ten o'clock; at first violent shivering, alternating with moderate heat

until noon, afterwards a predominance of heat, with slight shuddering, until evening; also,

copious nocturnal sweat, great thirst by fits (esp. during the shivering), respiration short, anxious,

impeded and fainting, with a feeling of constriction in chest, sensation of weakness and of

oppression in pit of stomach, and in chest generally; tickling in larynx, with frequent fits of short

coughing; violent frontal cephalalgia; anorexia during and after the attack, white tongue, covered

with a thick coating on r. side, and great weakness.—Coldness of whole body; heat, with

tendency to perspire, esp. on face; tendency to perspire excessively.—Thirst before the chill and

through the whole fever; often only before the chill, not during the chill, but again during the

heat.—Drinking < the violence of the shaking chill and the coldness.—At the end of the heat,

perspiration with heat.

Clinical

Clinical (part 1)
Clarke
  • Alcoholism.
  • Alopecia.
  • Amenorrhcea.
  • Angina pectoris.
  • Asthma.
  • Cardialgia.
  • Cough.
  • Croup.
  • Deafness.
  • Debility.
  • Diarrhoea.
  • Dysmenorrhcea.
  • Dyspepsia.
  • Emphysema.
  • Faintness.
  • Gall-
  • stones.
  • Gastralgia.
  • Hemorrhoidal discharge.
  • Hay-asthma.
  • Heart, affections of.
  • Hysteria.
  • Meningeal headaches.
  • Millar's asthma.
  • Morning sickness (of drunkards; of pregnancy).
  • Morphia
  • habit.
  • Palpitation.
  • Pleurisy.
  • Psoriasis.
  • Rigid os.
  • Seborrhoea.
  • Shoulders, pain in.
  • Tea, effects of.
  • Urethra, stricture of.
  • Vagina, serous discharge from.
  • Vomiting, of pregnancy.
  • Wens.
  • Whooping-

cough.

Clinical (part 2)
Clarke

Characteristics—Matthew Lobel, whose name is given to this family of plants, was a physician

and botanist attached to the court of James I. There are two British species, L. Dortmanna, found

  • in shallow lakes, and L.
  • wrens, which grows in heathy places.
  • L.
  • inflata, the North American

variety, is the most important of all, medically. According to Hale, this plant was used by the

Indians as an emetic detergent, in the same way as Verat. alb. was used by the ancients to

produce "Helleborism." But the chief modern exponent of Lobelia is Samuel Thompson, of New

Hampshire, who founded the modern Botanic School. His chief remedies were, besides Lobelia,

cayenne pepper and the vapour bath. There can be little doubt that he accomplished much with

these, but his unbounded faith in Lobelia led, in some instances, to fatal poisoning. Such a result

is not altogether unknown in qualified practice; but as Thompson had no medical degree these

cases brought him into trouble.—The records of them have furnished some of the symptoms of

  • the pathogenesis.
  • Lob.
  • i.
  • probably obtained the name of "Indian Tobacco" from the similarity of

its action to that of Tabacum in producing intense nausea, vomiting, profound depression at the

epigastrium, and collapse. It was a true instinct On the part of Teste that led him to class Lob. i.

with Su/.; and though the provings and clinical experience do not fully bear out what he says

about its skin action, the results of botanic practice, confirmed by Cooper, show that it has an

antipsoric action, and relieves morbid states due to the suppression of discharges. In a paper read

  • before the Brit.
  • Hom.
  • Society, November 1, 1888 (MZ.
  • H.
  • Rev.
  • , xxxii.
  • 717) Cooper explains that

he got no good out of Lob. i. until under the advice of a herbalist he used a solution of Lobelia

made with common vinegar. Here is one of his cases. A young woman, 23, of consumptive

family history on both sides, had, when 14 to 15 years old, severe pain in left, and sometimes

right, side, and round lower abdomen, with faint feeling. This lasted till the monthly period came

on regularly and then she was well till 20, when diarrhoea came on, which nothing was able to

check and which kept her in bed for months at a time. The symptoms were: Pains all round

abdomen and up the back, much < after undressing, feeling of exhaustion or failing to pieces

inside and out, cannot bear anything to touch her. Four or five motions daily when taking

medicine; if she leaves it off continual motions all day; it literally runs from her: watery,

sometimes light-coloured, sometimes dark, never bloody. Menses very irregular, sometimes five

to six weeks between; all symptoms, especially diarrhoea, < then; much tenderness all over

abdomen, especially in ovarian regions, legs ache fearfully, pains all over body; faints

continually. Since the illness began subject to neuralgia of face, one or other side or both,

extending to chest, coming and going suddenly at any time. In spite of treatment of all kinds,

Clinical (part 3)
Clarke

including that of a skilful repertorian, she grew worse. She went into a hospital, and there a small

pile was removed with but temporary benefit; and after this the vagina as well as the rectum

  • began to discharge copiously an excoriating fluid.
  • Lob.
  • i.
  • ac.
  • @, eight drops three times a day,

was now given. She began to improve at once, and in a few weeks was quite well. In this case

the difficulty first showed itself when the menstrual era was commencing; was relieved when the

flow was regularly established; reappeared simultaneously with menstrual irregularity. In the

next case there was an analogous history. A lady of 52, when 37, was exposed to a severe chill

which checked the catamenial flow. After this she had threatened phthisis with bronchorrhea,

which after two years gradually went off, leaving her subject to severe constantly recurring

seizures of vertigo. Nine months before coming under Dr. Cooper's care she felt as if something

was forming in the utero-vaginal region, causing much bearing down. She was obliged to go to

bed, and then there occurred a profuse pouring away of apparently serous fluid from utero-

vaginal and vesical mucous membranes, with paroxysms of agonising, burning, and scalding, <

in evening. Vagina swollen, extremely tender, bathed in moisture; urination always very painful

and followed by paroxysm of general scalding. She was unable to sit up and decubitus could

only be maintained with the knees drawn up, or on the left side. At night she would be awoke by

finding her back resting in a pool of water, and the sense of uterine bearing down was almost

intolerable. The bowels were unaffected; urine free from all but a trace of albumen. A hardness

  • and dulness to percussion existed all down right side of abdomen.
  • Lob.
  • infl.
  • acet.
  • @, 1/3 drop

every four hours. From that time the patient had not to keep her bed for a single day, and all her

  • symptoms cleared up.
  • The Lob.
  • i.
  • was in this case assisted by Nat.
  • chlor.
  • (Lig.
  • Sode chlor.
  • of B.

P.), 1/3 drop doses occasionally, which relieved the bearing down more than anything else. All

that remained of the illness was a slight weakness in lower abdomen felt every autumn. Cooper

recalls in connection with these cases a symptom recorded by Jahr: "Violent pain in the sacrum

with fever supervening upon suppression of the menses during their flow." Alongside this action

of Lob. i. may be placed another, also vouched for by Cooper, the power of eliminating foreign

substances like that possessed by Silica. A woman got a piece of mutton-bone down her

windpipe and into one of the bronchia. She was taken to the London Hospital, but the idea of

  • operation was abandoned as hopeless and she was sent out.
  • Lob.
  • i.
  • ac.
  • @ was given, five drops

three times a day. Soon a most violent cough was set up, in the course of which the patient

  • coughed up a large quantity of fetid, pus and finally the bone.
  • B the action of Lob.
  • i.
  • in

determining to the periphery it meets a large number of conditions due to suppression, including

cases of phthisis. Cooper adds the following note to the above: "The interest of knowing that

Lob. i. meets very serious symptoms connected with a profuse flow of serous discharge from the

utero-vaginal mucous surfaces is to some extent marred by my having employed the acetous

preparation, and subsequent trials of it would certainly have been made with the fresh plant

  • tincture had I been able to obtain the living plant.
  • As it is, my inferences, re the action of Lob.
  • i.
  • ,
  • are all derived from the acetous tincture.
  • The indications for Lob.
  • i.
  • are difficult to discover,

being broad and general rather than precise and localised. Its power over serous discharges from

mucous surfaces accounts probably for its influence on certain very obstinate forms of chronic

diarrhoea, these being more serous than watery, and it is probably owing to a similar influence

over sebaceous secretions that it removes in time the most obstinate wens on the scalp, causing

them sometimes to gradually disappear and at others to point and discharge their contents, and

that it causes the hair to grow when used locally in seborrhcea capitis. It is particularly called for

in ailments that never finish up, whether beginning from acutely inflammatory causes or not; it

also fights with symptoms occasioned by mechanical irritants in a way that I have never found

Clinical (part 4)
Clarke

any remedy do, e.g., where a spicula of bone presses on the brain (compression) or where a bone

  • is lodged in bronchus.
  • The late Dr.
  • Coffin (Botan.
  • Jour.
  • , Aug.
  • , 1849, p.
  • 271), in a boastful way,

professed to cure children and adults whose lives were despaired of from poisoning by various

substances by (decoctions? of) Lobelia, but whether by directly evacuant action or not it is not

stated. But in my own hands a few drops mixed in water cured a baby of severe convulsions that

I afterwards found were caused by a diabolical nurse giving the little one Chlorodyne. In

symptoms existing along with hereditary syphilis and in the tuberculosis of childhood it acts with

full power; in tabes mesenterica, in persistent earaches and headaches due to suppressed

discharges, where the lips are dry and hot and continual feverish colds are prominent, it is

  • specific.
  • Here it stands side by side with Ars.
  • iod.
  • and our foremost antipsorics.
  • In severe

inflammatory conditions existing along with anthrax, or with malignant deposits in different

regions, Lobelia in repeated as well as in single doses will often arrest urgent mischief. A few

  • drops of Lob.
  • i.
  • ac.
  • in boiling water takes away the pain and tension of inflamed piles; the patient

sits on a utensil thus filled. In the broncho-pneumonia of childhood and in imperfect recoveries

from chest affections, especially where tubercle threatens, Lobelia is indispensable. Treatment

with Lobelia should always be begun with a single dose, if the symptoms permit, as in some

cases it produces violent depression. In veterinary practice it is said to have proved curative in

the tetanus of horses; a disease it is also said to produce. It must be kept in mind when studying

Lob. i. that the herbalists used it in two forms: the decoction to produce emesis, and through

which they seem to have obtained its antidotal action, or by virtue of which they aborted acute

gout; and the acetous tincture, which they gave in chronic diseases, and in moderate

  • doses.
  • "—Lob.
  • i.
  • may cause a rash which exfoliates, and it has cured many cases of psoriasis.
  • It

meets a condition in which the secondary digestion is at fault. The patient is thin, poor, and has

no appetite. It cures the condition which favours pediculi corporis. Referring to the skin action of

  • Lob.
  • i.
  • , Hale quotes P.
  • H.
  • Hale as saying that, with the intense nausea it causes, there is

sometimes a prickling itching of the skin, and acting on this hint P. H. Hale thinks he has seen

benefit from its use in suppressed urticaria, with nausea and vomiting. The symptom Teste gives

is this: "Eruption between the fingers, on the dorsa of the hands and on the forearms, consisting

of small vesicles accompanied by a tingling itching, and resembling the itch pustules exactly."

As with Su/ph. "faintness at the stomach" is a grand characteristic which will be found in a large

  • proportion of the cases calling for the remedy.
  • Jeanes, who proved Lob.
  • i.
  • , gives these as the

chief symptoms: "Constant dyspnoea, < by slightest exertion and increased to an asthmatic

paroxysm by even the shortest exposure to cold; sensation of weakness and pressure in the

epigastrium, and rising thence to the heart with a constant heartburn; feeling as of a lump or

quantity of mucus, and also a sense of pressure in larynx; pain in forehead from one temple to

the other; pain in neck; in left side; high-coloured urine; weakness and oppression in

epigastrium, with simultaneous oppression of the heart." I have italicised "rising thence to the

heart" because I think this a particularly characteristic feature. There is something like it in the

cesophagus; a kind of globus hystericus. Hale quotes Dr. Cutler's (allopath) account of his own

case. He had been asthmatic ten years, liable to very severe and prolonged attacks, and during

the intervals scarcely ever passed a night without more or less of it, and as often as not was

unable to lie in bed. In the middle of an attack he had a tablespoonful of afresh plant tincture. In

three or four minutes his breathing was quite free; but there was no nausea, and thinking that

necessary he took another spoonful ten minutes after the first, and this occasioned sickness. Ten

minutes later he took a third, and this produced a sensible effect on the stomach coats, and a very

little vomiting and "a kind of prickling sensation through the Whole system even to the

Clinical (part 5)
Clarke

extremities of the fingers and toes. The urinary passage was perceptibly affected, by producing a

smarting sensation in passing urine, which was provoked by stimulus on the bladder." But all

these symptoms very soon subsided, and vigour seemed to be restored to the constitution which

he had not experienced for years. The necessity of taking Lobel. in doses sufficient to cause

pathogenetic symptoms was insisted on by Thompson, and though it led to some disasters seems

to have been the means of saving some lives. Thompson tells how as a boy he chewed this herb

and so learned practically its effects. He used to give it to other boys out of sport. One day whilst

mowing he gave a sprig of it to a companion. By the time they had got six rods the man said he

thought the sprig would kill him: he never felt so ill in his life before. He was in a profuse

perspiration, trembled all over, and was as pallid as a corpse. Unable to walk, he lay down and

vomited "two quarts." He was helped to his house; ate a good dinner, and returned to work in the

afternoon. After this he "felt better than he had for a long time." This gave Thompson his first

notion of the medicinal virtues of Lobel. In Walter Besant's Life of Edward Henry Palmer, the

great Orientalist, Palmer's own account of his cure by Lobel. is given. In 1859 he was seized with

pulmonary disease, which rapidly increased until he was told he had probably only a few months

  • to live.
  • On the advice of a herbalist named Sherringham he took a single large dose of Lobel.
  • i.
  • ,

and this is what he experienced: (/) Violent attack of vomiting; (2) cold chill mounting up from

feet to hands, which he could no longer move; to heart, which ceased to beat; to throat, which

ceased to breathe. A doctor was sent for. "I felt myself dying," he said afterwards, describing the

experience I was being killed by this dreadful cold spreading all over me. I was quite certain that

my last moments had come. By the bedside stood my aunt, poor soul, crying. I saw the doctor

feeling my pulseless wrist, watch in hand; the cold dews of death were on my forehead; the cold

hand of death was on my limbs. Up to my lips, but no higher, I thought I was actually dead. I

could see and hear but not speak, not even when the doctor let my hand fall on the pillow and

said solemnly, "He is gone!" There was no pain, he said, and he was in no concern except about

  • a book he wanted to finish.
  • He recovered suddenly.
  • New strength came to him.
  • The consumption
  • was arrested and was no more trouble to him for the rest of his life (H.
  • W.
  • , xviii.
  • 405).
  • —The

prickling sensation experienced by Cutler is characteristic, as also is tenderness of the sacrum.

  • Carleton Smith (#7.
  • P.
  • , viii.
  • 272) thus describes these: Extreme tenderness over sacrum; cannot

bear even pressure of soft pillow; cries out if any attempt is made to touch the part; she sits up in

bed, leaning forward to avoid contact. After each vomiting spell breaks out all over with sweat,

  • followed by sensation as if thousands of needles were piercing her skin from within out.
  • Lob.
  • i.
  • is

indicated in whooping-cough with dyspnoea threatening suffocation. Must keep mouth open to

  • breathe.
  • The headaches of Lob.
  • i.
  • are remarkable.
  • Teste describes them as follows: Pressive

headache, at occiput, less frequently at the forehead, sometimes one-sided (left), < by motion; in

evening and especially at night. Continual periodic headache, in afternoon and increasing till

midnight, every third attack being alternately more or less violent. The brain is racked by the

cough, which causes an intolerable pain. Heat and sweat about head and face, Cooper has

  • recorded this case (MV.
  • H.
  • R.
  • , xxxiv.
  • 289): Girl, zt.
  • 9, seized with very bad headache affecting
  • whole head and continuing night and day for two days, Merc.
  • and Verat.
  • v.
  • being given in vain,
  • Lob.
  • i.
  • acet.
  • @, two or three drops in a little water given in the morning after a bad night, gave

immediate relief and restored the appetite. Cooper considered it a meningitic headache, and he

  • finds Lob.
  • i.
  • ac.
  • and Kali iod.
  • 30 especially useful in these (excessive sensitiveness being a

leading indication for the latter). A headache that has been frequently verified is: "Dull, heavy

pain passing round the forehead from one temple to the other, immediately above eyebrows."

Headache following intoxication; < afternoon till midnight; < from tobacco. A peculiar symptom

Clinical (part 6)
Clarke
  • of Lob.
  • i.
  • is semilateral coating of tongue.
  • —Sudden pallor with profuse sweat.
  • Gastric
  • derangements, extreme nausea and vomiting.
  • The nausea of Lob.
  • i.
  • is continuous and

accompanied by constant flow of saliva. This is the indication for it in morning sickness and in

effects of suppressed or missed menstrual period. Vomiting; face bathed in cold sweat. The

nausea of Lobel. has been used in the same way as that of Tabac. and other emetics to produce

relaxation of muscles, as, for example, rigid os. Sometimes this is effected by direct

physiological action, but it may be homceopathic as in this cured case: "With every uterine

contraction violent dyspnoea, which seems to neutralise labour pains; rigid os, and perineum."

But it is also of service locally, as in an enema; also in cases of difficult catheterism. G. W.

  • Boskowitz (H.
  • R.
  • , xv.
  • 357) relates the case of a man, 40, who had twice had gonorrhea, the

second attack, three years before, having left him with a gleety discharge. For a year the stream

had been diminishing until at last it took him half an hour to empty the bladder. Many surgeons

had tried to pass an instrument and had failed. Boskowitz also failed several times, until one day

he dropped fifteen drops of Lob. i. @ into the urethra and held the meatus, to retain it, for five

minutes. It produced a smarting which soon passed away; and then No. 10 sound passed with

ease. This sound was passed twice a week until No. 24 entered easily, and after this there was no

  • further trouble.
  • Boskowitz has used Lob.
  • i.
  • in many similar cases with like success.
  • Guernsey

gives this as a leading indication when found prominent: "Urine has a deep red colour and

deposits a copious red sediment." Dyspncea (as well as nausea) occurring in connection with

  • imperfect menstrual evolution may indicate Lobe/.
  • H.
  • M.
  • Broderick (Med.
  • Adv.
  • , xviii.
  • 568) has

recorded this case: Young lady, 18, ill two years under allopathic treatment. Symptoms:

Laboured breathing, sense of tightness across chest compelling her to take deep inspirations,

which caused pain in heart region. Pulse full, very rapid; cough after each deep breath. Unable to

lie down from oppression and pain. Twitching of muscles of face. Menses never regularly

  • established; would go several weeks over time and then would last only a day.
  • Lob.
  • i.
  • 3x was

given in water. After the second dose she went to bed and slept. The remedy was repeated just

before next menstrual period. She had no more attacks and menstruation became normal. Among

  • the peculiar sensations of Lobel.
  • i.
  • are: As of lump in pit of throat.
  • As of foreign body in throat.

As if cesophagus contracted from below upward. As of a lump or heavy load in stomach. As if a

  • lump rose up to meet food and obstruct.
  • its descent.
  • Fulness in trachea as if from chest.
  • As of a
  • lump in larynx.
  • As if the heart would stand still.
  • As of a band about chest.
  • As if blood stagnated

in chest (> moving about). As if thousands of needles were pricking her skin from within

  • outward.
  • Lobel.
  • i.
  • is suited to persons with light hair, blue eyes, and fair complexion; inclined to

be fleshy. Symptoms are < by touch (right deltoid sore. Sits up in bed, leaning forward to avoid

contact with bedclothes on sacrum. Cannot bear even a soft pillow over sacrum. Pressure at

epigastrium = oppression). Motion; slightest exertion <. Bending forward < pain under right

shoulder-blade. Effort to move = fainting. Every rapid movement = dyspncea and suffocation.

Going up or down stairs < dyspncea. Symptoms generally > afternoon, < evening and night.

Rapid walking > sensation of congestion, weight or pressure in chest as if blood from extremities

  • was filling it.
  • Sickness (of pregnancy) < morning.
  • Coldness > by warmth.
  • Cold < dyspnoea; <

from current of air. Warm food = vomiting. Headache is < by tobacco or tobacco smoke.

Relations

Relations
Clarke
  • Antidoted by: Ipec.
  • Compare: The other Lobelias; Digit.
  • and Tabac.
  • (heart

affections; vomiting; < by motion sudden pallor with profuse sweat); Ars. (hay fever; gastric

  • troubles) Verat.
  • alb.
  • (gastric troubles); Ipec.
  • (asthma—but Lob.
  • i.
  • has, with the asthma, weak

sensation at epigastrium spreading up into chest, nausea, salivation, feeling of lump in stomach);

  • Ipec.
  • and Ant.
  • t.
  • (morning sickness).
  • Nux (morning sickness of drunkards; Lob.
  • in fair people,

Nux in dark); Bry. (< by movement; cough = headache); Asaf. (reversed peristalsis); Sul.

  • (occipital headache; cough = headache); Ab.
  • n.
  • and Thuj.
  • (effects of tea); Lact.
  • ac.
  • (vomiting
  • with profuse salivation—Merc.
  • at night); Lil.
  • t.
  • (pain at heart—Lob.
  • 1.
  • at base, Lil.
  • t.
  • , apex); Daph.

i. and Rhus (semilateral coating on tongue; with Rhus the coating is white); Kali i. (meningitic

headaches).

Relationship
Boericke

Antidote: Ipec.

Compare: Tabac; Ars; Tart e; Verat; Rosa.

Lobelia syphilitica or cerulea (gives a perfect picture of sneezing influenza, involving the posterior nares, palate, and fauces. Very depressed. Pain in forehead over eyes; pain and gas in bowels, followed by copious watery stools with tenesmus and soreness of anus. Pain in knees. Prickling in soles. Great oppression in lower part of chest, as if air could not reach there. Pain in chest under short ribs of left side. Dry, hacking cough. Breathing difficult. Dull, aching pain over root of nose. Eustachian catarrh. Pain in posterior part of spleen). Lobelia erinus (malignant growths, extremely rapid development; colloid cancer of the omentum; cork-screw-like pains in abdomen; great dryness of skin, nasal and buccal mucous membranes; distaste for brandy; dry, eczematous patches covering points of first fingers. Malignant disease of the face. Epithelioma).

Posology

Dose
Boericke
  • Tincture, to thirtieth potency.
  • Locally the tincture is antidotal to Poison-oak.
  • Often the Acetum Lobelia acts better than any other preparation.
  • Lobelia hypodermically acts clinically almost precisely as the antitoxin of diphtheria does upon the infection and renders the system stronger to resist future infections (F.
  • Ellingwood).

Classical Posology

Acute
  • 30C or 200C · repeat every 1–4 h depending on intensity
  • Stop on improvement · reassess in 24–48 h
  • For sensitive / elderly / paediatric: prefer LM1 or 30C
Constitutional
  • 200C or 1M single dose · wait 4 weeks
  • Alternative: LM1 daily × 10 days · ascend on retest
  • Hering's-Law follow-up adapts the next script
Citations: Organon §246 (interval / repetition) · §161 (plussed water) · §282 (LM ascension) · Kent on selection · Vithoulkas on second prescription. Open Repertify for the case-specific dose with the rule cited inline.
For practising licensed homeopaths

You've read the picture. Now run it against your case.

Open the workspace. Type a real case from this week — one you're still chewing on. Watch Repertify rank Lobelia against the totality, cite the rubrics, and surface the §246-correct posology with the rule inline. You'll know by the third turn.

Open workspace →
30 days free · no card required · cancel anytime